Evaluation Rubric
Evaluation Rubric
Malloy Five Stage Model of Ethical Decision Making
80 points
| Recognition of Ethical Dilemma or Cause | |
| Critical components: a) gathering relevant facts, b) proper chronological order, c) who was present, their roles, responsibilities and understandings (tacit and explicit) 20 pts | |
| Identify and enunciate the ethical Maxim(s) to be used | |
| Critical components: a) Generation of alternatives from all three perspectives (good, right, authentic), b) Creative critical thinking. Ability to build a case from each perspective using facts and well constructed reasoning. 20 pts | |
| Time | |
| Critical components: a) Time before b) the time of the incident, c) consequences that resulted 10 pts | |
| Identify and discuss extenuating circumstances | |
| Critical components: identify special or extenuating circumstances that could influence the decision 10 pts | |
| Render Judgment | |
| Critical components: a) Judgments are explained and reasons for them supported. 20 pts | |
| Total | /80 |
SES
480
Evaluation Rubric
Malloy
Five
Stage Model of Ethical Decision Making
8
0 points
Recognition of Ethical Dilemma or Cause
Critical components: a) gathering relevant facts, b)
proper chronological order, c)
who was present, their roles,
responsibilities and understandings (tacit and
explicit)
2
0 pts
Identify and enunciate the ethical Maxim(s) to be used
Critical components: a) Generation of alternatives from all three
perspectives (good, right, authentic), b) Creative critical thinking. Ability to
build a case from each perspective using facts and well constructed
reasoning.
2
0 pts
Time
Critical components: a)
Time before
b
)
the time of the incident, c)
consequences that resulted
10
pts
Identify and discuss extenuating circumstances
Critical components: identify
special or extenuating circumstances that
could influence
the decision
1
0
pts
Render Judgment
Critical components: a)
Judgments are explained and reasons for them
supported.
2
0 pts
Total
/
8
0
SES 480
Evaluation Rubric
Malloy Five Stage Model of Ethical Decision Making
80 points
Recognition of Ethical Dilemma or Cause
Critical components: a) gathering relevant facts, b) proper chronological order, c)
who was present, their roles, responsibilities and understandings (tacit and
explicit) 20 pts
Identify and enunciate the ethical Maxim(s) to be used
Critical components: a) Generation of alternatives from all three
perspectives (good, right, authentic), b) Creative critical thinking. Ability to
build a case from each perspective using facts and well constructed
reasoning. 20 pts
Time
Critical components: a) Time before b) the time of the incident, c)
consequences that resulted 10 pts
Identify and discuss extenuating circumstances
Critical components: identify special or extenuating circumstances that
could influence the decision 10 pts
Render Judgment
Critical components: a) Judgments are explained and reasons for them
supported. 20 pts
Total /80